3

Let's say someone runs 100 Tor instances on their machine and with their high speed internet connection -> download huge volumes of data through all of those instances.

Are there any mechanisms within Tor to prevent such misuse?

  • You want to limit bandwidth while setting up your relay? – Ron Aug 29 '15 at 16:44
  • @Ron No i was wondering, if somebody did such a setup as above(large downloads), would'nt that lessen the bandwidth for other users? does tor protect other users against this? – wolfgang Aug 30 '15 at 4:50
2

Tor doesn't differentiate between "good" and "bad" traffic. For the network is no difference if there are 100 new users doing their stuff or one person with 100 instances. So if one user decides to do this experiment there is less bandwidth left for other users.

It is slower to download a 50KiB file with 100 concurrent connections (ca. one second for each) than a single 5 MiB file (ca. 10 seconds):

Time to complete a 50 KiB request Time to complete a 5 MiB request

So Tor seems to work better the larger the file is.

You asked about a user who runs 100 downloads of large files. Currently Tor advises a bandwidth of over 100 Gbps and consumes around 60 Gbps. So there are 40 Gbps spare bandwidth. If every download has a bandwidth of more than 400 Mbps it would certainly cause problems. However 40 Gbps cost quite a lot of money. So I guess this can't be done by a single user, at least not for a really long time.

total bandwidth

  • 1
    What about one user doing 100 simultaneous different downloads? he has a huge bandwidth and hence runs major downloads on each instance – wolfgang Aug 30 '15 at 13:45

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.