I’m currently working on Roster, a tor project that aims to reward relay operators with good relays.

Besides the obvious requirements of a good relay (e.g. speed, geo-diversity, constant uptime), what qualities make a relay valuable to the Tor network and its users?

While this may not have a definite answer, I would appreciate all opinions on the matter.

1 Answer 1


I'll give it a shot:

  • consistent fast speed being #1
  • rewards based on total bandwidth available/consumed per period
  • total consistent uptime
  • Identity verification (at least online or via email)
  • Community involvement (member of tor-relays, tor-talk, etc)
  • Number of successful responses to complaints
  • Hosting in a country that the Tor Network needs for geo-diversity
  • bonus for multiple relays properly configured as a family
  • rewards for a more open exit policy (e.g. :)
  • running latest version of Tor or how fast the system upgrades
  • running a server following best practices guide checklist (FDE, strong passwords, maintained patch levels, etc)
  • Optional flags (e.g. HSDir, directory mirror)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.