10

Why is Tor implemented in the C programming language? Was that decision a matter of luck or taste of Tor's inventors? Are there any advantages of implementing this kind of technology in C?

16

It's a complicated question.

The main reason is historical. When we started out, Roger was only really comfortable in C and Perl. I knew more languages, but I didn't join Tor as a serious contributor until Roger had already been working on the project for a while. (Even if I had been doing as much of the initial work as Roger did, I'm still not sure I would have gone with something else. Back in 2002, Java wasn't so mature, and .)

That said: in my opinion, there are some parts of a program like Tor that you really must implement in C or some other compiled low level language. I'm thinking of cryptography in particular: in order to do fast, safe, efficient cryptography, you really need access to the CPU instruction set. (Some people would argue that C is too high-level for good cryptography, and all crypto should be done in assembly.)

But that doesn't mean that C is the best implementation language for all of Tor today. I'd prefer to move to an architecture where only the core networking module and a bit of glue code would be implemented in C, and the rest would run sandboxed in other processes, written in more high-level memory-safe languages.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.