0

Some apps (which have a built-in Tor daemon) will not work on TAILS or Whonix (ie systems that force all their traffic though the Tor network) because this creates a Tor-over-Tor connection. Why?

Examples of such apps:

  1. OnionShare
  2. Feather Wallet

I understand that OnionShare works by creating an Onion Service, which is more complicated than apps that just connect as a client to Tor (eg Tor Browser).

And I also understand that running Tor-over-Tor is not advised. Sure, it will have performance (and privacy?) degradation. I understand that. But I'd expect that these apps would just run slightly slower. The reality is they completely break. Why?

Please explain [a] "like I'm 5" and also explain [b] "like I'm a Tor developer" why some apps with built-in Tor daemons fail to run on a system that forces all its traffic through Tor.

1

1 Answer 1

1

Relays on the Tor network do not allow Tor-over-Tor. This is to avoid circuit amplification attacks on the network. I would guess that this is designed to prevent malicious clients from wasting a lot of the network's bandwidth by having traffic loop through the network many times before exiting.

You can read some discussion on the tickets:

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.